My phone is starting to ring again. It always rings, but it rings more right before Covid-19 cases begin to escalate. The calls have to do with exposure scenarios. Frequently, these do not fit into the guidelines so Dr. Wallace and I discuss them to try to come up with reasonable guidance. I thought it would be good to review the different types of tests that are available out there. This is a good article from the FDA’s website. There are some new tests like Abbott’s Binax test https://www.abbott.com/BinaxNOW-Test-NAVICA-App.html#/which is less accurate than PCR, but faster and cheaper. Quest offers an at home test, but I’m not sure of it’s accuracy nor of that of the saliva test offered by Costco. More when that becomes available.
https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/coronavirus-testing-basics
Coronavirus Testing Basics
You’ve probably heard a lot about coronavirus testing recently. If you think you have coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and need a test, contact your health care provider, local pharmacy, or local health departmentExternal Link Disclaimer immediately. The FDA has been working around the clock to increase the availability of critical medical products, including tests for the coronavirus, to fight the COVID-19 pandemic. Learn more about the different types of tests and the steps involved.
Types of Tests
There are two different types of tests – diagnostic tests and antibody tests.
- A diagnostic test can show if you have an active coronavirus infection and should take steps to quarantine or isolate yourself from others. Currently there are two types of diagnostic tests which detect the virus – molecular tests, such as RT-PCR tests, that detect the virus’s genetic material, and antigen tests that detect specific proteins on the surface of the virus.
- An antibody test looks for antibodies that are made by your immune system in response to a threat, such as a specific virus. Antibodies can help fight infections. Antibodies can take several days or weeks to develop after you have an infection and may stay in your blood for several weeks or more after recovery. Because of this, antibody tests should not be used to diagnose an active coronavirus infection. At this time researchers do not know if the presence of antibodies means that you are immune to the coronavirus in the future.
Different Types of Coronavirus Tests
Molecular Test | Antigen Test | Antibody Test | |
---|---|---|---|
Also known as… | Diagnostic test, viral test, molecular test, nucleic acid amplification test (NAAT), RT-PCR test, LAMP test | Rapid diagnostic test
(Some molecular tests are also rapid tests.) |
Serological test, serology, blood test, serology test |
How the sample is taken… | Nasal or throat swab (most tests)
Saliva (a few tests) |
Nasal or throat swab | Finger stick or blood draw |
How long it takes to get results… | Same day (some locations)
or up to a week |
One hour or less | Same day (many locations)
or 1-3 days |
Is another test needed… | This test is typically highly accurate and usually does not need to be repeated. | Positive results are usually highly accurate but negative results may need to be confirmed with a molecular test. | Sometimes a second antibody test is needed for accurate results. |
What it shows… | Diagnoses active coronavirus infection | Diagnoses active coronavirus infection | Shows if you’ve been infected by coronavirus in the past |
What it can’t do… | Show if you ever had COVID-19 or were infected with the coronavirus in the past | Definitively rule out active coronavirus infection. Antigen tests are more likely to miss an active coronavirus infection compared to molecular tests. Your health care provider may order a molecular test if your antigen test shows a negative result but you have symptoms of COVID-19. | Diagnose active coronavirus infection at the time of the test or show that you do not have COVID-19 |
There are some new diagnostic tests available with alternative methods and benefits.
- Rapid, point-of-care diagnostic tests use a mucus sample from the nose or throat but can be analyzed at the doctor’s office or clinic where the sample is collected and results may be available in minutes. These may be molecular or antigen tests.
- At-home collection tests, available only by prescription from a doctor, allow the patient to collect the sample at home and send it directly to the lab for analysis.
- Saliva tests allow a patient to spit into a tube rather than get their nose or throat swabbed. Saliva tests may be more comfortable for some people and may be safer for health care workers who can be farther away during the sample collection.
Molecular Tests
Many companies and labs have developed tests to diagnose COVID-19 based on detection of the virus’s genetic material in a sample from the patient’s nose or throat. These steps may change as new technology becomes available, but currently the typical steps in molecular testing are:
- A doctor, pharmacist, or other health professional orders a COVID-19 test. All COVID-19 tests, including those used with a home collection kit, require a prescription or order from a health professional.
- You or a health care professional use a specialized swab to collect mucus from your nose or throat.
- You or a health care professional put the swab in a sterile container and seal it for transport to a lab.
- During the shipping process, most molecular test swabs must be kept within a certain temperature range so that the test will be accurate. The sample must arrive at the lab within 72 hours.
- A lab technician mixes chemicals with the swab to extract the genetic material of any virus that may be on the swab.
- The lab technician uses special chemicals, called primers and probes, and a high-tech machine to conduct several controlled heating and cooling cycles to convert the virus’s RNA into DNA, and then make millions of copies of the DNA. Some tests use only one warming cycle to make copies of the DNA.
- When DNA binds to specific probes, a special type of light is produced that can be seen by the machine and the test shows a “positive” result for infection with SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.
The FDA continues to work with test developers to make more coronavirus tests available to more people in the future.
Molecular diagnostic tests that detect the genetic material of the virus are commonly used for diagnosing COVID-19 or active coronavirus infection. But no test is 100% accurate all of the time. Some things that may affect the test’s accuracy include:
- You may have the virus, but the swab might not collect it from your nose or throat.
- The swab or mucus sample may be accidentally contaminated by the virus during collection or analysis.
- The nasal or throat swab may not be kept at the correct temperature before it can be analyzed.
- The chemicals used to extract the virus genetic material and make copies of the virus DNA may not work correctly.
Antigen Tests
Antigen tests usually provide results diagnosing an active coronavirus infection faster than molecular tests, but antigen tests have a higher chance of missing an active infection. If an antigen test shows a negative result indicating that you do not have an active coronavirus infection, your health care provider may order a molecular test to confirm the result.
Antibody (Serology) Tests
Antibody tests may provide quick results, but should not be used to diagnose an active infection. Antibody tests only detect antibodies the immune system develops in response to the virus, not the virus itself. It can take days to several weeks to develop enough antibodies to be detected in a test.
How Coronavirus Tests May Be Used
Americans rely on the FDA to provide an independent review of medical products, such as drugs, diagnostic tests, and other medical devices. During a public health emergency like the COVID-19 pandemic there is an urgent need for products to diagnose, treat or prevent a medical threat. There are two ways a coronavirus test might be used for this emergency:
- Emergency Use Authorization (EUA)In certain types of emergencies, the FDA can issue an Emergency Use Authorization, or EUA, to provide more timely access to critical medical products that may help during the emergency when there are no adequate, approved, and available options. The EUA process is different than full approval or clearance because in some emergency situations we cannot wait for all of the evidence needed for full FDA approval or clearance. Instead, the FDA evaluates the options very quickly using the evidence that is available, carefully balancing the risks and benefits of the product as we know them, in addition to evaluating other criteria. FDA has issued many EUAs for diagnostic tests and antibody tests.
To expand the nation’s COVID-19 testing capacity, the FDA also issued a policy guidance offering regulatory flexibility in certain circumstances. The policies in this guidance apply to commercial manufacturers and to laboratories certified under the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) to perform high-complexity testing and who create laboratory-developed tests (LDTs) for coronavirus. In the guidance, the FDA outlines policies for test developers that offer certain types of COVID-19 tests before they receive an EUA for that test, under the circumstances described in the guidance. Under certain policies in the guidance, the test developers validate their test, give notice to FDA, and submit an EUA request within a specified timeframe.
- State Authorization of LDTsThe FDA is providing flexibility to states that want to authorize labs certified to conduct high-complexity testings in that state to develop and perform coronavirus testing. Under this policy, the state or territory takes responsibility for the safety and accuracy of COVID-19 testing by laboratories in its state/territory and the lab does not submit an EUA request to the FDA.
Coronavirus Testing In Your Community
The best way to get a coronavirus test is to contact your health care provider. You may also visit your state or localExternal Link Disclaimer health department’s website to look for the latest local information on testing.
Report Adverse Events
The FDA encourages health care professionals and patients to report adverse events or side effects related to the use of coronavirus tests to the FDA’s MedWatch Safety Information and Adverse Event Reporting Program:
- Complete and submit the report online through the FDA’s MedWatch website.
- Download the form or call 1-800-332-1088 to request a form, then complete and return to the address on the form or submit by fax to 1-800-FDA-0178.
- Emergency Use Authorization (EUA)In certain types of emergencies, the FDA can issue an Emergency Use Authorization, or EUA, to provide more timely access to critical medical products that may help during the emergency when there are no adequate, approved, and available options. The EUA process is different than full approval or clearance because in some emergency situations we cannot wait for all of the evidence needed for full FDA approval or clearance. Instead, the FDA evaluates the options very quickly using the evidence that is available, carefully balancing the risks and benefits of the product as we know them, in addition to evaluating other criteria. FDA has issued many EUAs for diagnostic tests and antibody tests.